Why did James and parliament fall out? Flashcards Preview

A Level History (Stuarts) > Why did James and parliament fall out? > Flashcards

Flashcards in Why did James and parliament fall out? Deck (7)
Loading flashcards...
1
Q

Issues over religion

A
  • James wanted to be tolerant with the Catholics
  • In 1606 after the initial concerns of Catholic extremism
    had died penal laws against Catholics deteriorated.
  • parliament continued to make their unhappiness
    towards Catholics made apparent. MP’s complained
    about papists in high places, the spread of popery and
    the slack enforcement of the penal laws.
    -
2
Q

James’ economic difficulties

A
  • Parliament disapproved of James’ extravagant lifestyle
  • Pushed James into substantial amounts of debt while
    also meant that it cloaked the real issue of the lack of
    regular income. As MPs witnessed James’ excessive
    spending they were able to argue that if he was more
    frugal them there would be no issues.
  • Resulted in the breakdown of the Great contract,
    parliament feared with an independent income James
    would call no more parliaments
  • James needed money, he was in debt and in
    increasingly desperate need of it, yet parliament
    refused to provide it
3
Q

Foreign policy (Spanish Match )

A
  • The growth of faction in court added to James’
    difficulties with parliament
  • The factions were largely divided by foreign policy,
    some favoured a peaceful FP , some wanted a more
    hostile FP to Spain to whom that they still saw as a
    serious threat
  • James was prepared only to fight in a just war, he
    preferred diplomacy and negotiations
  • James believed the best way to make amendments
    with Spain was through a Spanish match, yet parliament
    would not allow this as it was clear any children as a
    result of the match would be brought up as Catholics,
  • This was stressed in 1921 parliament in which the
    commons stressed that they wanted to see Charles
    married to a protestant. In fact they accused James of
    breaching his royal prerogative by discussing the
    personal affairs of the monarchy with a foreign nation
4
Q

Foreign policy (30 years war)

A
  • Engulfed much of Europe after the protestant nobility of
    Bohemia revolted against their newly elected king
  • They offered the throne to Frederick of the palatinate ,
    James Gods son
  • Frederick was quickly attacked by Spanish Habsburgs
    and Archduke Ferdinands forces, defeating them
    rapidly
  • James made it clear that over a million pounds would
    be needed to send an army to the Palatinate, yet the
    commons only voted for two subsidies adding up to
    140,000 pounds
  • The Mps feared a backlash from their freinds if they
    increased taxes in order to support a war subsidy. A
    single subsidy was all they offered.
  • This seriously angered James, parliament demanded
    James take action yet refused to help fund it
5
Q

What were the four fundamental reasons for the strained relationship between parliament and James

A
  • Religion
  • Economic difficulties
  • Foreign policy
  • James’ favourites
6
Q

How did James’ relationship with his favourites also add to the discontent with parliament

A
  • When James I travelled to London in 1603 he brought
    with him his favourites from Scotland.
  • While it would have been natural for James to bring
    with him his favourites, these men were to play a major
    part in alienating James from Parliament and the
    people.
  • Many MP’s were greatly angered that they were being
    bypassed in the decision-making process and that a
    huge amount of the advice given to James came from
    non-elected men – who also came from Scotland.
  • What caused the most resentment in London and n
    among the influential rural gentry was when Scottish
    favourites gained a title. The most notorious was when
    Robert Carr of Ferniehurst who was knighted in 1607
    and then made Viscount Rochester in 1611. Carr was a
    coarse man who brought discredit on the English court.
  • Carr was relatively poor, however James changed this
    gifting him Sherbourne castle to elevate is social
    standing
  • Parliament resented this, that a Scottish man of lower
    class was given so much power
7
Q

Explain the outcomes in the most significant parliament across James’ reign

A

1604: Went poorly, disputes over the Buckinghamshire election - led to angry speeches from James and MPs. The situation worsened when James emphasised his wish for a full union between his two kingdoms. The English cordially detested their northern neighbours in Scotland and regarded the Scot’s presence at court with deep suspicion and loathing
1606: Atmosphere of patriotic thankfulness filled the session when it resumed, after the Gunpowder Plot of November 1605. Doubts over the King’s extravagance were overcome in a desire to show him how relieved they were that the Plot had failed. However, quickly their suspicions resumed.
1610: Dominated by negotiations surrounding the 1610 Great Contract.
1621: The most pressing means was the Palatinate and the best means of securing it for Frederick. However, parliament were more concerned with the Spanish Match and eager to see England take the lead in the Protestant cause - petitioning that James’ son Charles may be timely and happily married to one of his own religion. This clear infringement of James’ prerogative led to a series of sharp exchanges.
1624: Conditions were worse in the 1624 parliament - Charles and Buckingham had returned from Madrid bent on war revenge - and their mood fitted the nations. James had lost control over both his throne and parliament - Charles held strong influence in the Subsidy Act, Statue of monopolies and the Impeachment of Cranfield.